Welcome to
The Hive
At The Hive, we bring together a dynamic community of HR leaders, compliance experts, technologists, and thinkers who care about getting identity, hiring, and trust right.
Expect practical insights, bold ideas, and real-world stories from across the employment and identity landscape. Not just from ZipID, but from people like you. Because when we swarm together, we build smarter.
What E-Verify is Not Telling You
Setting the record straight on what E-Verify does and does not do to support employers.
What E-Verify Is Not Telling You
E-Verify was designed to help employers navigate the Form I-9 process — offering what many assumed would be a comprehensive, one-stop compliance solution. The promise: help employers verify that new hires are who they say they are and are authorized to work in the United States.
Here's the problem: E-Verify doesn't verify identity. And it only minimally supports verification of the ID documents your new hire hands you.
What the Law Actually Requires
The Form I-9 obligates every U.S. employer to validate two things for each new hire: identity — that the individual is who they claim to be — and work authorization — that the individual is legally permitted to work in the U.S.
A U.S. passport covers both. Alternatively, a combination of documents can be used, such as a state-issued driver's license for identity plus a Social Security card for work authorization. There are over 190 valid document combinations and nearly 1,000 types of legitimate IDs accepted for the I-9. Without access to the issuing databases — and the ability to match the document to the actual human presenting it — it is impossible for employers to truly authenticate these IDs on their own.
What E-Verify Actually Does
E-Verify provides indirect access to limited government databases and performs two functions. It verifies that a name matches a Social Security Number via the Social Security Administration. And for three specific document types — U.S. passports and passport cards, Permanent Resident Cards, and Employment Authorization Documents — it displays a stored photo from government records so the employer can compare it to the physical document.
That photo comparison is helpful. But it is not an identity check. There is no 1:1 biometric match between the face on the returned image and the face of the person standing in front of you. There is no check to determine whether the identity was stolen and placed on a new ID. There is no verification that any of the fields on the document presented by your new hire match what the government actually has on file.
What E-Verify Cannot Do
Despite its name and intent, E-Verify cannot verify the ID document itself. It cannot check for duplicate or known fraudulent SSNs. It cannot verify that a passport number matches State Department records, or cross-check Permanent Resident Cards and EADs against USCIS issuance data.
On driver's licenses — which represent the majority of I-9 document presentations — E-Verify checks approximately 38 state DMV databases to confirm data fields, but not the states that decline to share that data. Fraudsters know exactly which state IDs are not cross-checked, and they exploit that gap deliberately. E-Verify cannot validate the authenticity of military IDs, Coast Guard IDs, tribal documents, or Canadian driver's licenses. It cannot detect fake, altered, or borrowed IDs. It provides no fraud determination capability whatsoever.
So Why Use E-Verify?
E-Verify is still worth using — not because it guarantees identity or work authorization, but because it provides three real benefits. It enables remote Form I-9 completion via video conference for enrolled employers, eliminating the need for costly third-party authorized representatives. It recently added death records to its SSN database to reduce use of deceased individuals' numbers, though this is not a real-time continuous effort. And it provides credible good-faith documentation — if audited by ICE, employers can point to a valid E-Verify result as part of a compliance record.
But make no mistake: E-Verify cannot protect you from a bad hire using false credentials. It was never built to do that.
Biometric identity verification — matching a live selfie to the ID photo at the moment of hire — is the only way to close that gap. That's what ZipID does.
Janice Kephart is the Founder and CEO of ZipID, former counsel to the 9/11 Commission, and Homeland Security Director at MorphoTrak (now IDEMIA). She has testified before Congress 19 times on identity-related issues.
Ready to verify your new hires with confidence? ZipID completes the entire Form I-9 process in under 8 minutes, fully compliant with 8 CFR § 274a.2.
Schedule a Demo | View Pricing
Frequently Asked Questions
Is ZipID ICE-compliant I-9 software?
Yes. ZipID satisfies all five federal electronic I-9 system requirements under 8 CFR § 274a.2 — including compliant audit trails, electronic signature protocols, and secure storage standards. It is specifically designed to meet the March 2026 ICE reclassification that elevated common errors to substantive violations.
As of January 2025, I-9 paperwork violations carry fines of $288 to $2,861 per form under 8 CFR § 274a.10(b)(2). Knowingly hiring unauthorized workers carries fines up to $28,619 per worker for repeat offenses. ICE audit rates in 2025 ran at least ten times higher than the prior year.
ZipID is pursuing certified E-Verify third-party agent status by August 2026. Currently, after the employer signs the I-9, ZipID redirects to E-Verify and automatically populates the resulting case data into the Additional Information field — preserving the complete record for audit purposes.
What is NIST and why does it matter for I-9 verification?
NIST — the National Institute of Standards and Technology — is the federal agency that sets accuracy benchmarks for biometric identity technologies. For I-9 compliance, NIST validation matters because it provides an independent government-verified measure of whether a facial recognition system is reliable enough to trust. ZipID uses NIST-tested algorithms rated at 99.998% accuracy.
ZipID's 1:1 facial recognition is rated at 99.998% accuracy using NIST-validated algorithms — fewer than 2 mismatches per 100,000 verifications. Liveness detection is built in to confirm the selfie is from a real, present person rather than a photo or deepfake.
OCR — Optical Character Recognition — reads and extracts text from government-issued IDs. ZipID uses AI-powered OCR to instantly capture a new hire's ID data and automatically populate the required Form I-9 fields, eliminating manual entry and typos. The AI layer also cross-checks extracted data for logical consistency and flags tampered, synthetic, or spoofed documents.
ZipID uses NIST-validated biometric facial recognition to match a live selfie to the photo on the new hire's government-issued ID. AI-powered OCR extracts and autofills document data. Fraud detection runs in the background checking for tampered, synthetic, or spoofed documents.
Facial authentication is entirely the employer's choice. It confirms that the new hire is who they say they are and that the ID they present matches their live self — especially valuable for remote hires, high-security roles, or industries with elevated identity fraud risk.
How long does it take to complete an I-9 with ZipID?
ZipID completes the entire Form I-9 process — including identity verification, document capture, and E-Verify redirect — in under 8 minutes, for both remote and in-person new hires.
ZipID is an I-9 compliance and identity verification platform that combines facial recognition, OCR document capture, and fraud detection to verify new hire identities and complete Form I-9 in under 8 minutes — with a legally compliant audit trail built in. It is the only I-9 platform built by the person who helped write the federal identity doctrine behind the law.
Who built ZipID?
ZipID was founded by Janice Kephart, former counsel to the 9/11 Commission and a national security identity expert with 25 years of federal and private sector experience, including designing border biometric workflows at MorphoTrak, now Idemia. Kephart authored the federal identity doctrine and biometric entry-exit recommendations underlying today's I-9 compliance framework, and has testified before Congress 19 times.